*** Read my 2 year update on page 2, after this ***
I have dated the same girl for going on 9 years now. I am 25, we started dating at 16, neither of us have been with another person. Over the last 4 years I have been having major problems going deeper into the relationship. I don't want to marry her because I am too unsure. she has lied to me ALOT in the past, but she was young. We have broken up several times over the last few years, because I'm mostly unhappy dealing with all of her "how do you feel about me etc?" questions.
I'm worried that I suffer from "grass is greener" on the other side complex. I constanlty find myself wanting to be with other girls physically. It's so hard for me to want to stay. I feel so shallow because I want a younger, prettier girl or one that has some sort of future. I hate her family and she hates nearly everything that is funny to me. I feel stressful around her but can't leave because I'm afraid to be alone. I have stayed with her too long and feel like I can never find another now. All of our friends and families on both sides tell us to split up because they can see we are not happy... I'm just so worried that I will not be able to find another girl better then her. She really is obsessed with me and I'm afraid she will kill herself if I leave. She has said this in the past and I believe her. I really just want a break to see other people and possibly return in the future. She said this is cruel and she could not handle it. To top it off, I'm 25 years old and have problems getting erections with her already... I think it's because she gained 50 pounds and I'm bored of her or hate her truly...
In her defense:
she is very sweet and innocent
she would be good with children
she is fairly pretty, chubby, not really fat
more background:
my parents and her parents was us to break up and so do all of eachothers friends
she hates all of my friends
neither of us are really active or do much outside of dinner,movies occasional vacation
neither of our hobbies coincide, but not many girls like pc games/marine life and boring techincal ******, nor do men really enjoy crafts and shopping online
we do like alot of the same movies
we argue about finances AND WE DONT EVEN LIVE TOGETHER by the way.
I dont really know if I love her.
Past breakups: immediate feelings
no crying from me, I actually usually felt relieved
around 2 weeks of being alone, I start to flip out, get drunk and get incredibly horny and call her... this results in it starting all over again.
How do you even break up with someone after this long?
What if I broke up, dated other girls and realized that I really did love her?
I need advice, preferably from older men with longterm relationship experience