You know the first part of your story hit home a little.. I was very closed when I met my bf... I am now so open and know that he is the same way you are. I appreciate it and I just needed to put my * * * * behind me. Don't get me wrong.. I still have my issues and insecurities but I really think that if she is not willing to compromise here then maybe you should take a second look.
For me, I am willing to do whatever it takes to keep my bf happy and the relationship well...
She may have had some issues but if she sees you hurting this much and can't stop to think about how it makes you feel then maybe she isn't right for you.
Again, I know I have some insecurities and mood swings.. but I can understand how it hurts my bf and I try to do right... I really try and mean well... i want him to be happy...
You should be happy too!