Schmenj,
I understand what you're saying.
But here's my thought: My ex-ex and I were together for many many years. We connect well on all levels except on how we want our relationship to be. Hence, the breakup 3 years ago. Took me a while to get over that. We became friends again about a year ago, and I realized that we will always be friends for a long long time. He's a very good man, a wonderful individual to be around. Family and friends are very important to me, and since I'm in this city alone, friends are family members. Good friends, truly good friends are hard to come by. And for that reason, and that reason alone I want to keep my friendship with my ex-ex.
Having said that, and as difficult as it is, I did cut off contact with my ex-ex to be with my new ex. I thought long and hard for 2 weeks before making that decision and finally told my ex of the decision. He asked how is he to know that I really mean it, and I say only time will tell and my action will tell. And to think I was naive enough to believe that was the only issue in our relationship. Soon after that, he started picking on other things, the hot and cold treatment persisted. I was again confused, and he wasn't sure if I was still his gf. We both, embittered, did exchanged some spiteful remarks. I realized that I didn't want to go down that path, so I asked for a time-out.
NC has been good, and thanks to all my good friends and you guys, I've been able stay strong for the most part. I cried everyday for the first week and felt like a zombie. I've stopped crying, but I've been angry for the past 3 days. I miss him terribly, but I can't bear the hot and cold treatment. I can't bear the thought that he's thinking if I'm worth keeping. One day I'm a god-send, and next day I'm not sure if I have time for you for the rest of the week. Please don't jump into conclusion that I was asking him to spend every waking and sleeping moment with me. I'm a professional - I work 50 hours a week, in the process of decorating my place, and have many social obligations. Even when we had our final discussion, he said that I was a great catch, like everyone else. But maybe he said it because he was trying to smooth things over, or out of guilt...I don't know...