Awwww you sound exactly like me lol. We gotta stop doing this. And our situation sounds similar where they actually reply back. And that gives us hope. Also I sent him an "I will always love you" song by WhitNey Houston. So we r in a similar boat, think we have similar personalities. But I think we should go on a long NC now. Whatever it is Atleast make them think. I almost wished him this morning because he messaged me "hey" yesterday. And i have ok idea that means lol. I was almost getting over.
Now on day 3. Ahh
The thing is when we try to message them we are thinking of the good things and ignoring everything we were unhappy about. If I think of those things I don't think I'd want to be with him forever anyways.