A little more info:
That day before I had caught them, I had gone to see a counselor, because I was so depresed and screwed up, and needed some advice on how to approach her about fixing our marriage. After the session I felt good and decided to go over to our house and make dinner for my family, help my daughter with homework, and put the kids to bed. The guy friend actually called our home phone while I was there. But, still my dumb thought he was just being a friend through difficult times for her. She seemed fine and dandy that night, which was brutal because I was dying inside. So after the girls went to bed I took off.
The next morning when I confronted her and she finally admited he was there all night, the first thing I asked was; How long has this been going on? She said, not until you moved out of the house. Which consisted of taking my clothes and CD's. She also said "we did not go all the way, I am on my period." But, What I heard ouside the window was enough for me to be discusted.
After a few days she wanted me to come over and talk. She tried to explain her story: that night after I left she was crying and all torn up inside. Then her friend called and said "do you need me to come over" she said no. Then he called back and said are you sure? She said well I guess so. They watched a movie, and one thing led to another, and you know the rest.
When I left that night she seemed pretty damn fine to me, and also when they were in our bed it was all fun and games. She is now telling me that this was the first time anything physical ever happened with them. When I ask her about what she said that morning "nothing happened until you moved out". She says she wasn't thinking clearly because she was intimidated by me confronting her about it. She also tries to justify it all because she says she was being pretty clear about us "needing a break", and "I thought we were on a break". But remember, she is the one that said "worst case scenario, if we do decide to date other people, we will DEFINATLY discuss it first.
Am I a fool to believe her about anything? To me when you are married there are no "Other People" to try to figure out if you are with the right person.
The last conversation we had I asked her "so what is the deal with you and this other guy now" and she cant give me a solid answer. She says she is just so confused. She still loves me so much, and it kills her to see me around the kids, because the kids love being with me. I said then I think we need a full separation, because I cant live with what happened, and I dont know if I can ever trust you the same way again. I said lets get together in a few nights and talk and write out all of the arrangements, i.e; Kids, House, Debt. The day that we were supposed to meet, she said she wants to atleast talk things out with a counselor. So I agreed, and we are going tonight.
By the way, I had no idea people would reply to my post so quickly, THANK YOU!!