Agile Wit

Sorry if my question was ambiguous. The key point I was trying to convey is how much weight physical attraction will carry vs. the personality. When asking, I assumed all other things were equal (like money status, marital status, etc. ) And no, this is not a survey, just something many men are often wondering about "Can I make up the appearance shortcomings with other, less tangible things?"

Let’s consider 2 guys: The “Smart Guy” is average-looking, but smart, charming, and generous. The “Handsome Guy” is very good-looking, but self-centered, selfish, and boring. Let’s assume all other things (like their material status) are equal. They both have a chance to strike up a conversation for say, 30 minutes, then ask for a woman’s phone number. In your opinion, what percentage of women will give their number to A. The “Smart Guy” B. The “Handsome Guy”