Ask For Advice
Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 11 to 19 of 19

Thread: Cut off my sister for good

  1. #11
    catfeeder
    Platinum Member catfeeder's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Location
    New Jersey
    Posts
    17,831
    Gender
    Female
    Thanked
    3451
    Quote Originally Posted by Batya33 [Register to see the link]
    Sounds like a toxic relationship. I will add this. When our father was dying last year and suffering from Alzheimers I had to help from afar because I moved away. I did my best. My sister lives closer and was able to provide the hands-on emotional support to my mother that I could not. I am all for not prioritizing family ties to excuse unacceptable behavior but consider whether you might need to be able to have good communication with her in the future for the good of your family. My sister and I barely spoke civilly until I was a teenager (she is older). She has her quirks (me too) and we clash sometimes but I love her to the ends of the earth and I know when our mother's time comes it will help so much that I have her in my life (and I hope I do!). Again not to pressure you to continue an unhealthy relationship just because she is your sister but please do consider the ramifications.
    I agree with this. On a scale of 1 to 10, there's an awful lot of real estate between the extremes. Part of maturity is responding with changes in our own behavior to find balance rather than reacting in ways that go off the deep end and cause dramas that generate a whole new set of consequences.

    The things you mention are based on her misuse of information you offered her.

    So why not just stop offering information?

    Just because someone asks you a question, that doesn't obligate you to answer. You can still be civil at family gatherings and cooperate in the care of your family, including your nephew, without setting yourself up for misery. I'd just block her on social media and no longer confide anything beyond the weather, but I wouldn't dramatize a big cutoff and position myself as her victim. That might feel great at the moment, but it won't buy you one grain of serenity when this role conflicts with your obligations and opportunities to engage the rest of your family when sis will be present.

    Head high.

  2. #12
    jennylove
    Platinum Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Posts
    1,088
    Thanked
    270
    Thanks again, everyone!!

    Batya, I've never bashed her parenting skills to her face, I'm just venting on here. There is a lot more that she's done than what I've listed. It just hurts. Everyone I know always tells me how lucky my nephew is to have an aunt like me, I've even had little kids actually ask me if I'll be their Aunt or sister because I'm just fun to be around. Lol. I have friends who are aunts and they do very very little for their N/N and they still get some sort of acknowledgment in the form of an invite to a recital or handmade card. I get nothing. And it hurts. Like I stated, last year, I actually told my sister that the only thing I wanted was a handmade card from him. Nothing. This year, my mom "hinted" about "thank-you's" by putting a package of cartoon-themed Thank You cards in my nephews stocking. Guess who used them to send thank you notes? My sister. At any rate, most humans have a basic need of wanting to feel important or loved by someone that they love and go to great lengths for.


    Catfeeder, I get what you are saying. And to be honest, it never truly hits me of her skeme until afterwards. She has quite the way of getting people to talk. I've been in despair and mourning and have let out my feelings, and she seems so caring, but she ends up using things against people. It just happens. I don't know, it's just not natural to me to be so guarded with what I say even though I know better.

  3. #13
    ~Seraphim ~
    Forum Supporter ~Seraphim ~'s Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Out of suffering have emerged the strongest souls; the most massive characters are seared
    Age
    50
    Posts
    30,729
    Gender
    Female
    Thanked
    4573
    Just remember this is not his fault he is not being taught properly . Look at who is raising him . So don't hold any ire for him .

  4. #14
    jennylove
    Platinum Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Posts
    1,088
    Thanked
    270
    Seraphim, in no way am I blaming him at all. No.

  5. #15
    ~Seraphim ~
    Forum Supporter ~Seraphim ~'s Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Out of suffering have emerged the strongest souls; the most massive characters are seared
    Age
    50
    Posts
    30,729
    Gender
    Female
    Thanked
    4573
    Quote Originally Posted by jennylove [Register to see the link]
    Seraphim, in no way am I blaming him at all. No.
    Ok, good.

  6. #16
    Batya33
    Platinum Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    42,168
    Thanked
    2575
    Quote Originally Posted by jennylove [Register to see the link]
    Thanks again, everyone!!

    Batya, I've never bashed her parenting skills to her face, I'm just venting on here. There is a lot more that she's done than what I've listed. It just hurts. Everyone I know always tells me how lucky my nephew is to have an aunt like me, I've even had little kids actually ask me if I'll be their Aunt or sister because I'm just fun to be around. Lol. I have friends who are aunts and they do very very little for their N/N and they still get some sort of acknowledgment in the form of an invite to a recital or handmade card. I get nothing. And it hurts. Like I stated, last year, I actually told my sister that the only thing I wanted was a handmade card from him. Nothing. This year, my mom "hinted" about "thank-you's" by putting a package of cartoon-themed Thank You cards in my nephews stocking. Guess who used them to send thank you notes? My sister. At any rate, most humans have a basic need of wanting to feel important or loved by someone that they love and go to great lengths for.


    Catfeeder, I get what you are saying. And to be honest, it never truly hits me of her skeme until afterwards. She has quite the way of getting people to talk. I've been in despair and mourning and have let out my feelings, and she seems so caring, but she ends up using things against people. It just happens. I don't know, it's just not natural to me to be so guarded with what I say even though I know better.
    I don't think it's fair to specify what you want him to make for you and then think of it is "all I want" - you don't know if he enjoys writing/drawing or not for example. If he made thank you cards for everyone except you I could understand it better.

  7. #17
    catfeeder
    Platinum Member catfeeder's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Location
    New Jersey
    Posts
    17,831
    Gender
    Female
    Thanked
    3451
    Quote Originally Posted by jennylove [Register to see the link]
    Catfeeder, I get what you are saying. And to be honest, it never truly hits me of her skeme until afterwards. She has quite the way of getting people to talk. I've been in despair and mourning and have let out my feelings, and she seems so caring, but she ends up using things against people. It just happens. I don't know, it's just not natural to me to be so guarded with what I say even though I know better.
    Growth and maturity into using discretion never 'feels' natural, because it's new skill development. It's a stretch--that's exactly what growth means. But it makes no sense to resist our own growth into responsible decision making just to dig in our heels and insist that others are at fault and must change to accommodate our lack of willingness to change. That's the opposite of growth, it's an adolescent temper tantrum.

    Growth mean noticing that whenever you press button A, B pops up, and you hate B, so doesn't it make sense to stop pressing button A?

    You've identified faults in your sister that you can either heed while rising above the battlefield, or you can continue to play out your position as the needy sister who gets burned. Try flipping your own behavior to adopt the role of The Adult in your relationship with sister. This means you can humor her to a safe degree while offering zero ammunition in terms of your secrets and private vulnerabilities.

    This guarded but cheerful position needn't last forever, but it's a tactical move to prevent yourself from being positioned badly, only to react to that with extreme drama. Instead, play the adult who listens to your family members instead of speaks. Answer questions with questions, or simply explain that you'll need to think about how much you'll want to speak about 'that'. This will create boundaries of both respect and privacy, and you'll likely thrive as you learn to use discretion to your advantage. You can modify these boundaries in the future should you see the kind of growth and change in others that inspires more degrees of trust. Until then, embrace your independence and learn how to wield it wisely.

    Head high.

  8. #18
    jennylove
    Platinum Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Posts
    1,088
    Thanked
    270
    Yes, he enjoys drawing/coloring, etc. his nickname is "Artist" at school. No, he doesn't send any of us any such thing and it bothers everyone to a degree. It's a nice gesture to teach your kids, it means a lot to the receivers, it's fun for the kid and may even give them the good feeling that "giving" gives, and it only costs postage. I may sound unreasonable to you, but it's really not a big request. I accept this is how it is though. I don't have to like it, but I accept it. If I ever have kids or step kids, I'll make sure they send stuff to family. That's all I can do.,

    Cat, Batya: You've given me so much to think about. I don't know what you practice in your career, but I gotta ask, is it in the field of psychology? Ive read some of your past responses to other people, you give the best advice even if it's not what one hopes to hear.

    My sister: as much as I don't like the things she's done, I do worry about her. I do think she is a borderline, but I really don't know. what worries me and the rest of my family the most is her marriage. He treats her horribly. I think she's so messed up psychologically, she is really waaaay out there more times than not.
    All of us know her marriage is horrible, controlling, no love, no respect. She's a stepford slave. No joke. Her husband has said/done horribly anti-social/sociopath things at family functions that it now makes everyone very uncomfortable to have him around, so we rarely have gatherings together anymore because we can't not invite him. We are civil to him and friendly and always have been.

    My sister used to make excuses for his behavior as soon as he'd do it or say it. She caught on how uncomfortable he makes everyone, I mean, his behavior would make Mother Theresa uncomfortable. I am confused about this: why does she come over and always make it a point to talk about how great he is, and wonderful and how happy she is, when nobody asks? Ten minutes later, she's bawling. 20 minutes later, she's complaining to my mom that his only downfall is he smokes pot in front of my nephew, cries some more, laughs, and then concludes with the finale of how great he is. Happens all the time.

    Why does she try to convince us of how wonderful he is and if how happy she is when we all know better? I think her "issue" with my boyfriend is that he is really is a nice guy and says nice things, and made people laugh, and actually spoke to my family like a true gentleman. And this behavior is opposite of her husband. So now he's competition? She doesn't want anyone to like him more than her husband? so many why questions.

  9. #19
    Batya33
    Platinum Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    42,168
    Thanked
    2575
    I think Catfeeder gave great responses! No- no background in psychology (sometimes too much of a background in Bluntology but I mean well) and thanks!

    When you have or adopt/teach kids you can teach them to send thank you notes (as I have)

    Also, if you don't follow Catfeeder's advice and choose to completely ignore her/not deal with her then I also would avoid speaking of her at all with your family (i.e. gossiping) - simply say "we're not on speaking terms right now so I wouldn't know how she's doing and it's not a good idea for me to hear about what's going on with her". Unless it's an emergency and you want to help out and support in a genuine way and need the information to do that.

  10.  

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Top Threads
My Christmas
I choose to live apart from my family because they tend to drive me batty. However, I have not been home for the holidays in 5 years, babies have
Asking for input from estranged children
Hello. I'm hoping that I can get some input from adult children who are estranged from their parents. My youngest son is 28, and has decided that
My mom trying to pick clothes for me
I'm tired of my mom trying to control the clothes I wear. I don't want her picking my clothes. I'm 26. It's so embarrassing. I miss it when I used to
Judgemental dad, how do i handle it
My dad hates that my boyfriend and i rent. And he is vocal about it. He even said he isn't comfortable at our place and that its a dump. He goes on
Am I wrong for this?
For those of y'all that be been on here a bit y'all have seen me post about mom and her declining health for a while now. She's back in the hospital

Expert Advice
Featured Threads
Is he still in love with his EX?
I met this great guy at work (last November), he just got out of a painful breakup (last September) during that time he kept communicating with his
Can't get over girlfriends past
I've been dating this girl for about 5 months and its going great. The only issue is that I can't get over her sexual history. There are several
I dont like my girlfriends new piercing
So my girlfriend went and got nipple piercings knowing that i didnt like them and didnt tell me she was gonna get them. They are a really big turn
What I am to her ?
hey guys I want some counseling .. I met a girl online .. At first she said that she doesn't wanna fall for me and we will be just friends .. I said
I want my family back
Hi, I was dumped on New Years Eve by my ex girlfriend of 8 years whom I have a 6 year old with. We have been arguing for the past few months prior to
Anxious and depressed about being 32 yo and not married
I could really use some kind and encouraging words right now because I wake up every morning to an intense feeling of pain because I am alone. I'm 32
Ex (dumper) delays giving keys back. Why?
First time poster. Been viewing threads somewhat regularly for a few months now and figured I'd get a few opinions. I'll give a little of the
Ask For Advice

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •