Ask For Advice
Results 1 to 9 of 9

Thread: In love with my friends girlfriend, anyone in the same situation?

  1. #1
    Mike747
    Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Posts
    6

    In love with my friends girlfriend, anyone in the same situation?

    So here's my story.

    I'm in love with my friend's girlfriend. They got together about a month ago. The thing is I'm 99% sure she really likes. I think she only went out with him because she's never had a boyfriend before and she wanted a relationship. To be honest I don't think they'll make a good couple, he seems to be more into her than she is into him.

    To make it even more complicated I've had a girlfriend for almost a year now. I want to say that me and the other girl haven't done anything (though I think we could have if we really wanted). I'm not a cheater. I've resolved to break up with my girlfriend in about a months time. To be honest my feelings for her started to diminish before I developed feeling for the other girl. I would have broken up with my girlfriend earlier but she's been studying for her repeat exams and I don't want to do it before she's finished them. I know it sounds horrible but I wish I was single when I got to know the other girl (I've known her a good bit longer than my friend has) the fact is I really like her. I haven't felt this way about a girl for a long time.

    Anyone been/have been in the same situation? Did you go for the girl? how did things work out?

  2. #2
    ItRainsItPours
    Silver Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Posts
    459
    Yeah I have been in the same situation before and I lost a good friend because of it. She is his girlfriend and you need to set your opinion of their relationship aside and respect it. Unless they break up and he verbally gives you the go ahead then you need to fall back. I agree that you should break up with your girlfriend.

    I have a feeling that you wont follow my advice but I wish you would. Good luck.
    Last edited by ItRainsItPours; 08-10-2013 at 12:36 PM. Reason: Typo

  3. #3
    NymphaeaLilly
    Silver Member NymphaeaLilly's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Age
    25
    Posts
    301
    Gender
    Female
    Thanked
    15
    You are not being a good friend nor a good bf. You don't seem like a good person with integrity. imo.
    You need to take in account feelings of other people around you not just your selfish wants. Don't be a spoiled brat and stop lusting after friends girls, they should ALWAYS be off limits!!!

  4. #4
    Mike747
    Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Posts
    6
    Quote Originally Posted by NymphaeaLilly [Register to see the link]
    You are not being a good friend nor a good bf. You don't seem like a good person with integrity. imo.
    You need to take in account feelings of other people around you not just your selfish wants. Don't be a spoiled brat and stop lusting after friends girls, they should ALWAYS be off limits!!!
    I know you're right. But what do you do when you really like her? when you can't stop thinking about her and feel the two of you would have something really good together? And to make it worse you're pretty certain she feels the same?

    People have even said we look like a couple.

  5. #5
    90_hour_sleep
    Platinum Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    bc
    Posts
    2,880
    Gender
    Male
    Thanked
    90
    Quote Originally Posted by Mike747 [Register to see the link]
    I know you're right. But what do you do when you really like her? when you can't stop thinking about her and feel the two of you would have something really good together? And to make it worse you're pretty certain she feels the same?

    People have even said we look like a couple.
    i'd say that if you're really sure, then you have your answer on what to do. if you're sure about someone else, then it's time to end the relationship you are in. no sense spending your time with someone you're ambivalent about. it's no good for either party. and then you let the cards fall where they will with the other girl. it may work out. it may not. these are the things we never really know. but have a bit of courage. take the risk. you may learn something about yourself...and others.

  6. #6
    tiredofvampires
    Forum Supporter tiredofvampires's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    In this world but not of it
    Age
    48
    Posts
    7,763
    Gender
    Female
    Thanked
    844
    I would, if I were you, consider this a wake-up call more than anything that you are with someone who you shouldn't stay with, and break up with your gf. You're right to wait until that can be done with less rupture in her life, since it's not long to wait.

    But I think you need to see that as an independent act, not connected to whatever happens with the girl you like/love. Because the truth is, for them to break up, it's going to take some sowing of the relationship they've started, seeing it decline -- chances are, she's not going to leave him on a dime. She might feel very confused for a very long time (since this is her first relationship, and she doesn't know herself well), and guilty...lots of messy feelings are going to happen, if indeed your feelings for eachother are mutual.

    And as someone else pointed out, you should also be thinking about how much you value your friendship with your friend, because if he's very hurt by the break-up, it's likely he won't take well to your starting to date her. Only if he didn't feel it was a loss or if he was over her would he give you his blessings. So you may lose that friendship.

    So chances are, it's not going to work out all happily ever after like you envision. Just be aware of that. But do take this as a sign that you can and should be loving someone more than you love the one you're currently with, and act accordingly to free yourself for whomever would be a better match (which would in turn free your gf for the same).

  7. #7
    Mike747
    Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Posts
    6
    Quote Originally Posted by 90_hour_sleep [Register to see the link]
    i'd say that if you're really sure, then you have your answer on what to do. if you're sure about someone else, then it's time to end the relationship you are in. no sense spending your time with someone you're ambivalent about. it's no good for either party. and then you let the cards fall where they will with the other girl. it may work out. it may not. these are the things we never really know. but have a bit of courage. take the risk. you may learn something about yourself...and others.
    I know I've had too many 'what ifs' in my life not to go for it. I'll lose a friend but I may win someone I love, I think its worth it.

  8. #8
    Mike747
    Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Posts
    6
    You're right. I think I would be breaking up with her anyway at this stage. The spark has gone.

    I wish I knew what she felt. She's so affectionate towards me and we get on so well, I think if I was single when I met her we'd be together now. I think she thinks my girlfriend and I aren't going to split up anytime soon and that's why she started going out with the other guy.

    I resigned to losing my friend. He's a long way from my best friend and he's pissed me off before, but still it's not an ideal situation. The crazy thing is with my previous girlfriend it was a complete reversal and he really liked her. He told me and I said it was fine, though that's mainly because he had no chance with her.

  9. #9
    Ms Darcy
    Platinum Member Ms Darcy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    United States
    Age
    34
    Posts
    28,840
    Gender
    Female
    Thanked
    3131
    In situations such as this, the noble thing to do is to end it with your gf asap and be single. Let their relationship be and do your best to move on from her.

    Right now, you are willing to sacrifice your friendship for your own desires. Not a sign of a good friend or a good boyfriend. Chances are if you "steal" her you will lose him and eventually lose her.

  10.  

Top Threads
Is it a deal breaker for most women if a man does not believe in marriage?
I don't believe in the institute of marriage and because of my lack of belief, I have no intention of getting married, I know marriage is important
Can anyone figure out how this guy really feels about me ?
This is a little bit complicated. Me and this guy we started off as really good friends for like a couple of years. At the time he was talking to
I don't want us to live next to his parents!
Hey everyone, I'm yet again back with another issue which I would like your advice on. Just quickly to say im in my early 20's as well as my
Is sexting cheating if it makes your relationship/sex life better?
So I've been with my boyfriend for five years and I love him. I wouldn't dream do anything unfaithful or that would hurt him. A (male) friend and I
Ladies Night, should I be jealous?
My girlfriend of ten years or so decided she was going on a ladies night with whoever and I found out because I snooped on her phone. Got jealous /
I have to choose. My best friend or my girlfriend.
First off I'm sorry if I, Andrew, Contradict myself in this. Please ask questions, if necessary. People : Andrew (18/M), Emily (17/F) , Sally
Please Help! (I think I'm going insane)
Hello All, I don't even know where to begin. I met this guy about five months ago through a friend and we were instantly attracted to each other

Featured Threads
Who is in the wrong?
This person isn't really a "friend" she is 24+ years older than me. I have a feeling I'm getting taken advantage of because of my age. I started
I became engaged with a girl who calls herself a "free spirit"......need clarity
I met a wonderful and bright girl 3.5 years ago and she by far stole my heart. She is appositely beautiful, funny, intelligent and outgoing. She is
Has anyone ever totally given up on finding love?
Hello everyone! Well I been wanting to post this for a few weeks now. I don't really know how to say it or word it. But, who here has or knows
Today "should" have been our 6 year anniversary
Today was suppose to be our 6th year together. Today is the first time on this date that we are not together. We made this date a big deal
Shoud I break up because my girlfriend hooked up with my cousin in t
I'm jealous because my girlfriend had casual sex with my cousin before she met me. We've been dating for a year, she's very funny, caring, sexy
I'm in love with my co-worker 😥
My coworker and I started working together about 10 months ago. We work closely together all day just the two of us mainly. From the day he started
Aggressive Courting
There's this girl I really, really like, and would really want to be in a relationship with. Unfortunately, recently I messed up, and now I think she
Ask For Advice

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •