Ask For Advice
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 15

Thread: why does she keep lying to me??

  1. #1
    xcci
    Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Posts
    6

    why does she keep lying to me??

    Sorry this may be a little long, but please if you guys have the time, I really need some help...

    so near the start of the relationship I asked my girlfriend about her past and she told me. I wasn't too happy, but it was bearable and I totally forgot about it and we both had an amazing time. But after awhile I heard something about her past which absolutely contradicted what she said to me. I asked her about it and after countless times of denying it, she finally admitted it was true. I was furious that she'd lie to me about something like this, and we got into a huge argument about it.

    But eventually everything settled down. I sat her down and asked her. "Is there anything else you've lied about? I promise I won't judge you, but you can't keep lying to me like this." and she looked me right in the eye and said, "no there's nothing else i swear. I realize my mistake and I'll never lie to you again because I know you'll accept me no matter what I've done in the past". So I asked her if it's okay that I call up one of her exes and ask him if that story was true. She said, "of course, I'll never lie to you again because I love you".

    So an hour or so later I call up her ex, and explained the situation. He talks to me for a bit and comes over to my house and shows me texts from my girlfriend right after our conversation telling him not to tell me everything else they did. At this point I was....almost losing control. How could she look me in the eye and lie like that??? I called her immediately and began yelling at her for lying to me like that. But eventually...somehow I calmed down again and forgave her. And she said all the same things. "I learned my lesson, I'll never lie to you again", etc etc.

    But I just couldn't let this go. It kept occupying my mind, and one day while thinking about what she told me. I realized that they didn't make sense. She had to be still lying to me. So when I saw her that day I asked her about it. She kept saying things like, "Oh i don't remember what happened" (which was obviously a lie). But I insisted that she explain why two things she told me didn't make sense. And eventually she admitted to yet another thing she kept from me.

    I sat her down again and asked her in a calm, patient manner, "Ok you really have to just stop lying to me. It's your past, I won't judge you for it but you can't just keep secrets from me". Eventually she admitted that she made out and did things with this guy that she now considers a "brother". I don't know if that's just me.....but isn't that a little screwed up? Making out with your brother...??? I wasn't even mad anymore I was just weirded out.

    In a nutshell, she lied to me four times. Each time, insisting that that was the end of it. That there was no more and that she'd never betray my trust again because she loves me. But obviously something had to change because I couldn't trust her anymore. I asked her not to talk to any of her exes anymore because it made me uncomfortable. She gladly agreed. But recently one of my friends told me he saw her having a nice long conversation with one of her exes. I sat her down again and asked her about it in a completely calm manner. I told her, "I know you're not the kind of person to be able to just ignore someone like that and cut them off completely, so I'll understand if you did. Please just tell me". And of course she starts lying to me again. But I keep questioning her and she eventually admits it. And this was all months after the first four times she lied. I thought this was all in the past and that she'd stop lying to me. Obviously not.

    I tried to talk to her about her compulsive lying and how it's really starting to become a serious problem. I asked her how she could just lie to my face over and over again like that. Saying things like, "I love you and I'd never lie to you". I mean....who the f*** can even do that??? Does she not have a single ounce of moral fiber in her body?? I just seriously don't understand her need to constantly lie to me when I'm trying to comfort her and be understanding.

    But today when I talked to her about it, she began crying (which she always does) and screaming at me. She said that it's scary when I'm angry and that's why she always lies to me. I admit, I did grab her once and yell at her to stop lying to me and I regret that. I've already apologized multiple times for that. But I've NEVER struck her or even hinted at the possibility. I do get violent when I get pushed over the limit, but I never let her see me like that. And I've never hit a person, I just beat the crap out of my punching bag and blast music to vent. So I don't understand where that is even coming from...

    Can I even trust this girl anymore? I handled the situation a little roughly at first because I couldn't accept the fact that she lied to me like that, but after once or twice I decided to try being understanding. But she STILL continued to lie to me. Am I doing something wrong? Because at this point I'm just confused and I really need some advice.

  2. #2
    DN

    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Posts
    42,515
    In the first place it isn't your business what she did with her ex, you have no right to cross examine her and you should under no circumstances grab her violently - no wonder she won't tell you anything.

    You owe her a huge apology and need to stop acting as if you own her now and have a right to know her past.

    There is only one person in the wrong here and that is you.

  3. #3
    pl3asehelp

    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Location
    San Francisco
    Age
    41
    Posts
    9,034
    Gender
    Male
    Though it may not be your business, if she's offered to discuss it, I would, like you, expect what she told me to be the truth. Otherwise, yeah, she's just lying to you and that alone is a very valid basis to lose trust in a person.

  4. #4
    xcci
    Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Posts
    6
    Quote Originally Posted by DN [Register to see the link]
    In the first place it isn't your business what she did with her ex, you have no right to cross examine her and you should under no circumstances grab her violently - no wonder she won't tell you anything.

    You owe her a huge apology and need to stop acting as if you own her now and have a right to know her past.

    There is only one person in the wrong here and that is you.
    I realize it was my mistake of asking her the details in the first place. I've learned my lesson about asking a girl her past because you're never going to like the answer. But I don't think I continued to ask because I really wanted to know her past. I just wanted her to stop lying to me and I couldn't force myself to stop questioning until I got the truth. And I already gave her multiple apologies for grabbing her, but I was just furious after she lied right to my face and went behind my back, telling the other guy not to tell me.

    I felt like I didn't even know her anymore. We had this kind of unspoken agreement where when we look each other in the eye and ask, "are you lying to me?" we have to tell the truth. No matter how bad it is, and I always thought that was sacred. I've told some lies here and there as well, but I always ended up telling the truth when she asked that. I just wouldn't be able to continue lying after looking her in the eye. But she broke that agreement like it was nothing.

  5. #5
    IBAMIE
    Member IBAMIE's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Posts
    11
    While I can agree that her past is not exactly relevant to your relationship, if you ask her something about her past and she tells you something, she should be honest. If she has lied to you on numerous occasions that you know about, it would be safe to wonder if she has lied to you about other things. The way I see it, if you lie to somebody about something that has nothing to do with them and has little consequence on anything to do with your relationship, then what else will you lie about? So I don't blame you for being upset that she continues to lie to you. But its not as if you have to sit there and accept it. You're not married to her and have no real commitment to her. So leave. It's really that simple. Rather than try and force her to "be honest" with you, why not stop wasting your time with someone who doesn't respect you enough to be honest with you?

  6. #6
    DN

    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Posts
    42,515
    She broke that agreement because she's scared of you.

  7. #7
    xcci
    Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Posts
    6
    Quote Originally Posted by DN [Register to see the link]
    She broke that agreement because she's scared of you.
    She broke that agreement before I grabbed her or showed any signs of being violent.

  8. #8
    DN

    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Posts
    42,515
    Quote Originally Posted by xcci [Register to see the link]
    She broke that agreement before I grabbed her or showed any signs of being violent.
    Was that before or after you yelled at her.

    Have you yelled at her before over anything else?

  9. #9
    xcci
    Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Posts
    6
    I suppose I have yelled at her before. Maybe once or twice, but it's definitely not a regular thing. And okay I guess being scared is a legitimate reason, but enough so to continue lying like that? Even when I'm being as considerate as possible and swear that I won't flip out or anything. And the reason I got mad was because of the fact that she lied. So I don't understand why she would lie again, unless she wanted to make me mad. Wouldn't it be smarter to just tell the truth?

  10. #10
    metrogirl
    Platinum Member metrogirl's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    So. Cali
    Age
    47
    Posts
    10,936
    Gender
    Female
    I don't understand your obsession with her past.

    Now I can understand why you would be uncomfortable with the whole "brother" thing, but the past should be off limits.

    And if you keep yelling at her and grilling her like a hotdog, you can expect one of two things,

    she's either going to keep lying to you

    or she's going to be your ex.

  11.  

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Top Threads
About to End a 4 year relationship from a disrespectful action. I can't take this anymore!
I've been with my soon to be ex-Fiance for over 4 years. His brother has a woman now his wife who has had a thing for him for years. She has spread
My bf lie to me about his smoking habbit
Me and my bf has been together from 8 years. We are truly in love with each other and committed to get married. I am also involves in his family and
Husband Secretly Obessed over another woman for 5 months.
I was on my husnands phone the other day. I was about to post a couple of screenshots i took on Facebook and next to my images in gallery were 2
She broke up because she doesn't trust me , but loves me
Hey, So here's our relationship summed up a bit. We have been together for a year and almost 3 months now. We broke up a few times there , but
Once a cheater always a cheater?
I know it is not black and white. There are times when it’s not applicable at all. But what do you all think or experienced? If someone was cheating
I don’t know if he is genuinely sorry?
He suffers from manic depression and before we dated was trapped in a mindset of “no consequences”. I come from a damaged past and he helped me feel
I messed things up bad and don't want to lose a good man
I don't know what is wrong with me. I met a wonderful man. Some months into the relationship, things started going south. Yeah, he cheated. But

Featured Threads
Moving in together with my almost one year boyfriend but one big issue
Dear All, I haven't been back here for a while now. I have decided to post here instead than in the "pets" section, because I didn't want to
Back from the holidays: waiting for him to contact me
I am back form my holidays. I went away three weeks. We had two great dates before I went away. During the holidays we texted a few times, the
Should I do it?
Maybe it’s because I’m such a nostalgic person, It’s going to be a full year since our breakup las January. I still think about her every f*cking day
He chose his lodgers side so I broke up with him but still love him
I just broke up with my boyfriend of one year because 4 months ago he let a friend move into his house with him she asked him ,and in turn he asked
Feeling unsure after 4 years and before marriage
Me and my fiancé are together for 4 years now, both in our mid 30s, had an engagement not long ago. We live in [B]MY [/B] apartment. I feel
Broke up with gf
So back story 4 months into the relationship. She knows about while she hasn't met my friends she knows of them. I know not much about her past. I
Girlfriend having abortion and says she needs time to herself. What do I do?
Hello, this is my first post in this forum and I am struggling and need a lot of help. 2 weeks ago my girlfriend found out she was pregnant, we are
Ask For Advice

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •