Jump to content

PLEASE - some advice!


Recommended Posts

43, male, married 19 years. 3 WONDERFUL kids.

 

My wife has said she wants a divorce - and I think she means it. She has said this many, many times before, but I think this time she's mustered the courage and resolve to act upon it.

 

For 19 years I've been the breadwinner. I make very good money, we have a very nice home, and no financial worries. She doesn't work outside the home and hasn't for a long time. In fact she never really did work much even before the kids. She stays home (her choice) and does an amazing job around the house. She does everything - painting, mowing, you name it. I work a bunch - but NOT over the top.

 

From the beginning, when I'm very honest with myself, there have been 'issues'. She hasn't kissed me in many, many years. Hasn't hugged me. Won't say goodbye or hello when I come and go. Not that she's been a monster (although she has been that - read further). We have had good times but loads of lousy times. Sex is almost unknown. I'm in good shape (and she is too - I think she's hot) but she's very very conservative. Has never initiated sex. Ever. I've gotten so tired of trying I've stopped trying.

 

She has never worked in a corporate environment, but will often tell me what to do when I try to tell her about my day. Says I'm weak, or not doing the right things at work - when in fact I'm very near the top of a successful and large company.

 

She criticizes me constantly. From how I drive, to how I leave a voice message, to how I don't think my day through. She complains that I don't do anything around the house - but I do more (and I'm not bragging) than ANY other guy I know. I don't care what other guys do, I do more - and I have an important job. She's never happy. Rarely smiles and surely rarely laughs.

 

She's a great mom. Loves the kids a ton.

 

She's told me on many occasions over the years that she didn't love me and doesn't love me. Told me I was a good way to get out of what she viewed as a bad home. No abuse or anything but it wasn't a happy house.

 

I want so much more. I want a wife who can smile and laugh. Who can hug me and kiss me. And who enjoys sex. Who respects me and supports me. But, I made a vow, and I don't take that lightly. Then there's the kids. We both love them so much and they are amazing. Smart, polite, mature. But they know that mom and dad have issues - you'd have to be blind to miss it.

 

She's thrown many things over the years (pots, a computer, knick-knacks). Has never apologized about anything. Ever. We haven't been out alone in 16 years - because she says she doesn't want to. She has no fun. Has no friends. Her motto: trust no one. Won't go on a real vacation.

 

We socialize mostly with my family and she puts on a good front when they are around - and she can be very gracious. But we have no other friends to speak of. I've let her control the whole thing.

 

So, here's what I need: someone tell me WHY is she this way? And WHY am I so stupid to deal with this?

Link to comment
  • Replies 166
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

She sounds like a classic abuser (yes, plenty of women are abusers). Divorce may actually be a good thing for your peace of mind, however, be very careful to protect yourself financially. If she is the way you describe, a divorce could get ugly with regards to custody and money. Make sure to get a good lawyer. She sounds like a very cruel woman and a very unhappy woman. Some poeple are just like that. Maybe she has a personality disorder...who knows what really happened in her childhood to trigger this kind of behaviour. You are not the only person who gets caught up and stays with someone who is this way. It becomes easier than rocking the boat. However, now that she is talking about divorce, maybe it is time for you to take the "bull by the horns" and take advantage of this opportunity to get out of this unhealthy and damaging situation.

Link to comment

Hey ST, sorry to hear that.

 

You´re not stupid... it just seems you keep insisting in going on with something that hasn´t work for years. Is more like you´re stubborn.

 

I made a vow, and I don't take that lightly

Marriges sometimes stop working. You already proved you do not take the responsibility of a house, a family and kids lightly, that´s more then clear. But the relationship with your wife is falling into pieces, just admit it. It doesn´t mean it didn´t worth it or that you don´t take it seriously. Making vows doesn´t mean you have to turn into a martyr for the rest of your life. You can´t go on like this. Unless you enjoy suffering, and I don´t think that´s the case. Yes, you are responsible of supporting a family, but what about your own needs?

 

WHY is she this way? And WHY am I so stupid to deal with this?

Hard to answer that only by reading a couple of paragraphs of your situation. Have you ever tried taking all this to a counselor?

Link to comment

This is just from my own personal experience of being the wife you described...

I acted the same way towards my husband. I acted that way because he wouldn't listen to anything I had to say, and he always had to have his way. I gave up arguing, it didn't do me any good. Everything in life was all about him. He always put himself before the kids and me. When the kids birthdays came around, it was me doing all the running around getting gifts, ordering cake, same with holidays, vacations etc. If I needed him to do something for me, he'd do it when he felt like it. I felt more like a mom than a wife. I began to withdrawl from him until our marriage crumbled. I fell out of love with him years ago, but he didn't notice until I filed for divorce.

I realized after all this time, I was more of a mom than a wife. My husband didn't have a clue what interested me, or even what my favorite color was for that matter.

Plain and simply, my husband didn't give me any attention. I don't know if this provides you the insight you were looking for, it may not even apply to your situation at all, these are just the reasons I acted the same way you describe your wife to be acting.

The best advice I can give you is to try to find a good marriage counselor, and to keep talking to her, let her know you care, and how seriously her actions are hurting you.

Best of luck to you!

Link to comment

Everyone thanks sooo much. I feel like I'm being eaten from the inside it hurts so much.

 

Rubiez: some of what you said sounds as if SHE said it! And there's some truth, maybe. She'll say I put my work before her and the kids. But she's been saying that forever and it's really not true. I work and travel only as much as the next successful guy. She just has NO clue of what the real world is - cause she doesn't live in the real world.

 

But I've done so much over the years for her. And it backfires. Examples: I've brought home flowers - and she says: don't buy me flowers, it's a waste of money. I bought her a beautiful diamond ring - she literally made me bring it back ("I don't wear rings"). I bought her lingerie once (ONCE!) and she said it was gross - it wasn't.

 

I try to offer opinions on couches, or drapes or whatever. But, c'mon, I'm a freakin guy too. I'm sincere but to a point. I don't hang around and watch football, drink beer, whatever. "Fun" to her is literally doing hard work around the house. And I do enjoy that as well. We like gardening and major renovations. BUT (BIG BUT), there's a point I'd like to take a bubble bath with my wife - and that has never happened.

 

She's more of a mom because that's all she will let herself be. It's hard to listen (and I'm not excusing any of my actions) but it's hard when you get yelled at for not correctly moving a coffee table. Long story but true.

 

Keep talkin to me, I need it!

Link to comment

What AM I going to do! That's what you all are supposed to help me with!

 

Therapy?! Pulease. I've been (alone) to 4 different people over the last 19 years. She won't go - because I'm the problem, not her. Last therapist I went to, after about 3 visits, told me "I don't have much hope for your marriage".

 

Okkkkkkkay - thanks for that. Will you LOOK at that, my time is up!

 

I would much rather not be divorced (my parents are divorced and it sucks, but I lived) but I really think there might be better out there.

 

She won't even consider therapy - and that makes me wonder why I even care.

Link to comment
What AM I going to do! That's what you all are supposed to help me with!

 

Yeah, is a pretty fair question. What are YOU gonna do after all. Noone is supposed to decide that but YOU.

 

So, what is it? Are you gonna:

 

A) Keep struggling

B) Leave it like that

C) End it

D) Find someone else

 

 

I would much rather not be divorced (my parents are divorced and it sucks, but I lived)

 

With all due respect, seems like your current situation sucks 10 times more.

Link to comment

HEY Soon -

 

MAN!! The first part of your post I was like....Is this MY husband?!?!!

 

Almost everything you said described my relationship with MY husband - even, I'm embarrassed to admit, the parts about her not being very nice to you.

 

I personally don't call my husband names but I do nag and complain quite often. Because like your wife, I'm not happy and want out.

 

How old are your kids? (I even have three kids!!)

Link to comment

Hey Awdree -

 

WOMAN!!!

 

Kids are 16, 14, 12.

 

Why do you want out? What do you want? What aren't you getting that you want to get?

 

Explain yourself to ME and maybe I can understand her!

 

Baby Carrot: the more i think about this, the more i believe i need out. I dunno...

 

WHY is she this way????

 

Awdree?

Link to comment

HEY STBX - I really hope I can help. I just hope I may have some insight....

 

FOR ME - Staying at home is a choice I made - to be with my kids. Mine are still small.

 

But I am going CRAZY!

 

I am not at all meant to be stuck at home with kids. It's just not the life I really feel was meant for me, I'm not at all suited for it. Yet, here I am. And for some -albeit crappy -reason, I resent my husband for it.

 

I COULD get a job B U T....there's ALWAYS some reason not to.

 

The kids are too small.

My husband -used to- travel

My skill set isn't high enough for me to make euff $$ to off set the cost of daycare

We run a business from our home and it really needs me.

 

But mostly, I'm not a very good "stay at home" "responsibilty" type person. I feel stuck...caged. And it's not ALL or ONLY that I blame him but he is unfortuanley the only other adult here whom I can take it out on...poor guy....

 

I just want out. I want to be free of the responsibilty of a house, kids, blah blah blah blah blah...

 

But here's the kicker FOR ME anyway........he told me the last time I brught it up...."Then go. You can take the van. Just go. I'll help you get a place, you can see the kids when ever you want, but if you need out, go."

 

Yet here I am and we've been doing really well......(so far) ever since

Link to comment

Awdree - some of what you say makes sense. She's never been truly happy - at least not for extended stretches. I'm a glass 1/2 full guy.. she's 9/10 empty. Her mom is exactly the same way. She's miserable.

 

MY wife blames my mom-in-law's outlook on my father-in-law. Which is very very hard to believe. The poor SOB has been tied to this so sad person for so long - and he's a very fun guy. IMHO. But my wife thinks that she and her mom bear NO resemblance. I'm like: are you KIDDING me?! You are twins!

 

But i believe my wife blames her dad for her mom's unhappiness just like my wife blames ME for her unhappiness. It's so twisted. I really reallly really want to stay with my wife - but for the life of me I don't know why. I know I could be so much happier even alone, much less with a loving woman.

 

My wife has said many times that she raised her brothers. Her mom never did anything and my wife 'lost' her childhood because her mom forced the younger siblings upon her. Some of that may be true. My wife takes enormous pride in our own kids. And my wife is waaaaaaaay too over-protective. She is, trust me.

 

So, in a weird way, you could argue that my wife still has major responsibilities. And she has said on a thousand occasions that I don't help, that I don't pay attention, that I don't think of things, that she is always required to think of everything, that all the responsibility is hers and that I don't ever help. The truth (my view) is I do more than the average guy and that my wife has such a ridiculously high expectation level of what should be done in life, of what level of performance we all should live to - that there is NO WAY I, or any man (or woman) could meet that level. I can't TELL you how p/o she gets when, say, the customer service rep from some company can't answer a question quickly enough. She'll take their head off even though, c'mon, in general those call centers are notorious for bad service.

 

Everything she does is with such perfection and attention. And if you don't do it the same way - look out!

 

I don't even know why I'm writing this. I just want a woman who will say "OK let's get an ice cream - just the two of us. The kids are fine alone - c'mon the oldest is 16 - and we can walk to the ice cream store."

 

Why? If i can understand it, maybe I can fix it???

 

Could your husband fix you??

Link to comment

Hi Soon tobex,

 

Welcome to the forum.

 

The problem I see here is that it takes two people both willing to work and put in the effort to make a marriage work, and, as you are learning, as hard as one person can try, if the other cannot, it isn't going to work.

 

You've put your own needs for sex, intimacy, and companionship on the back burner for a long time. I don't think anyone here is going to be able to explain why your wife is the way she is, and, since she isn't talking or willing to seek therapy with you, I don't see how you are going to find out.

 

Basically, it sounds like this is one of those situations where you either agree to continue to suffer unfairly in the marriage while you are denied the normal componants of a healthy marriage, or, you can file for seperation and show her how serious you are about this.

 

I really don't see how it can or should stay like it is for much longer.

Link to comment

I think he CAN fix me and is working desperately to do so. And BECAUSE of his efforts, I feel guilty and stay....bad reason, I know...I do really love him though, I really do. It's the life I hate....

 

My husband too does more than most men, I'm sure of it because I have 2 brothers and lots of married sisters....my husband is A FRACKEN SAINT comparatively. One thing I can say for sure is that although I love his ability to step in and save me, I think that is part of the problem I find myself in now. I hate to admit it, but I think he did too much and I got spoiled.

 

I too expect things to get done more quickly now. Whenever I get irritated or frustrated he's right there to make sure that pressure or stress goes away...so much so that now even the littlest bit is too much for me.

 

Part of me just wants to get out from under it and experience resolving problems on my own. Now WHO says THAT?!?

 

I personally can't WAIT until my oldest is 16 - 0r 13 for that matter and we can take a walk ALONE together....

 

My suggestion - and obviously take it or leave it, is to do what makes you happy EVEN if that means it comes at her expense. This has gone on long enough.

 

I mean really, your kids WILL be gone in less than 10 years!! THEN WHAT??

Link to comment

The 'strange' (I was going to say funny, but it ain't) part is that she says SHE wants the divorce - because I'm the problem. I've hurt her. I'm the problem, etc. etc. I don't really, really think she's going to hire a lawyer - but she might. I overheard her talking to a distant family member who had gotten divorced a while ago. I thought it was so inappropriate: Xmas Eve and she's asking this other woman (who's husband was a drunk, drug dependent, non-provider - a complete opposite of me) how she knew she was "ready to move on".

 

I'm like: are you KIDDING me?! You have a lovely home, great kids, a husband who would kiss you until the cows come home (if you let him) and you are "ready to move on"???

 

Maybe it doesn't matter. If she files, fine. I'm not going to fight for her. I'm tired of it. If she doesn't file... i dunno if i have the guts. She'll say "see, I KNEW you would leave me... I've said all along you'd do what your father did and leave" blah blah blah. My dad cheated on and left my mom. I have not and never would do that. Have sure thought about it over the years... but wouldn't!

 

She does NOT respond to threats well. She returns fire with LOTS of fire. She has a horrible temper and cannot have a conversation. I've seen her verbally assault people in the checkout line without big enough reason.

 

And she won't see a therapist. Never happen. I'd bet my life. She has an irrational abhorrence of Dr's in general.

 

I'm not perfect, not even close. But i've never cheated. I really would like a sweet, caring woman, mind you. But i want that woman to be her.

 

When I'm with her I feel so inadequate because I don't know how to deal with her. She's great at making me feel like an idiot. It's funny (no wait strange) - at work I'm the boss. At home, I'm bossed. Deep inside she wants to be controlled IMHO. She wants to be told what to do - that would relieve a lot of what she sees as the unbelievable daily pressure that is upon her. She's at once both angry and sad for her father. She feels that he made his mother unhappy (i disagree vehemently) and yet is sad that he didn't stand up, take the bull by the horns and say "straighten yourself out or I'm out".

 

I've thought about all of this for years. The kids are old enough and I will survive. Maybe it's time for me to go get a divorce decree. Two things can happen: 1) i get divorced or 2) she straightens out and we live happily ever after.

 

It's going to be 1) cause she just isn't smart enough or brave enough or confident enough to get help. So she'll shout from the highest mountain what a horrible man I am for leaving her. How right she was - see, he left. As she predicted.

 

I don't really, really care about that cause I think people are shaking their heads behind my back to some degree. Asking: how does he DO it?! But I don't really care because I know I've done what is reasonable. And she won't even consider seeking marriage therapy. I've said: "I'll sit in the office, wont' say a word, you tell your story" No dice.

 

The only thing that scares me is will she turn the kids on me. She can be manipulating but the kids are pretty centered. She's not a monster but she is tough. I hope the kids don't think I abandoned them.

Link to comment

The kids WON'T think that but I see your point.

 

I'm getting a pretty clear picture of her unhappiness...she's miserable. Whether or not YOU are the cause, her father is or she just likes being unhappy is - at this stage -a moot point.

 

BECAUSE......either way you are NOT responsible for her happiness. I mean, the happiness in her psche.

 

May I ask - what are her GOOD attributes. You list the ones you have issues with but there are reasons you want to stay. What are they? OUTSIDE familiarity, security and comfort ...

Link to comment
I'm like: are you KIDDING me?! You have a lovely home, great kids, a husband who would kiss you until the cows come home (if you let him) and you are "ready to move on"???

 

She is done with this marriage and has been for awhile. That isn't your fault, you have done all you can, but it takes two, and you just don't have that.

 

Let her blame you if you file. You would be the only one to take steps to bury something that was long dead anyway. There is no shame in that- you deserve a marriage, and that is not what this arrangement is anymore, and it has not been for a long time.

Link to comment

Awdree - her good points:

 

1) She can be very thoughtful. In a very low keyed way. Example: I like oatmeal. Ok this is weird - i really like oatmeal. And she has purchased like 20 boxes for me. I'm never out cause she knows I like it. And I like that about her. Another example: I have a long commute to work. I drink coffee in the car. My old mug spilled on my shirt the other week. She bought me a nice new one to replace it. It was so small and thoughtful.

 

2) She pushes me (in a good way). She's got unbelievable energy - I think she never stops moving so that she'll never start thinking about stuff. And her energy energizes me. I'll get up and help. Building things. Fix things. Make our house a truly lovely place. People stop and say "wow...this place was a dump and you guys have made it gorgeous". I like that. A lot. It's a hobby for us and we enjoy sharing it together. It CAN get waaaaaay out of whack - for example I really don't want to do it ALL THE TIME. But she has no other hobbies. None.

 

3) She's got a nice butt. Not that I ever get to see it. Sigh. But it's great in jeans. Hey, I'm a guy... at least i put this good attribute 3rd on the list and not 1st. But she does have a.. ok, I'll move on.

 

4) She a great mom and that has allowed me to become a great provider. I spend a lot of time w/ my kids. I really do. But without her being so great with them, there's no way I'd have been able to accomplish what i've accomplished - as meager as it is in comparison to bill gates.

 

5) She like to take rides and walk - which I love.

 

And...that's it. Wow. Why DID I get married? LOL Oh, right see 3) above.

 

She's not warm, soft, loving, sexual, sensual, silly. She rarely laughs, has never told a joke.

 

I know I'm not responsible for her happiness. But why does she say that I'm responsible for her UNhappiness?!?!?! That is so unfair and hurtful. How can a person with whom you've created such wonderful kids be so hurtful?

Link to comment

Soon - I suspect there was more than her butt that you liked about her when you first got married (are you sure you're not MY husband?? He CONSTANTLY says my bum is his favourite!)

 

I don't want to tell you to give up on your marriage of 20 years. That seems unnatural.....but dude...like I said, you're youngest is 12. In EIGHT ( 8 ) years, (s)he'll be in college! Then what are the two of you going to do?

 

OK - ya know what....I had a whole bunch of other stuff typed but this came to mind....I don't want to be judgemental, I try so hard to not...but SOMETIMES....

 

To be perfectly frank...sometimes part of the reason I don't leave is because of the money my husband makes and how much I would miss it. Being on my own would be MUCH, MUCH different financially.....could I be that shallow???? Man, I suck....

 

could that be part of her issue as well, ya think?

Link to comment

Hope - to the point. I like that. Hurts. But I like it.

 

WHY?!!?! Why is she done with this marriage? What have I done to be such a lousy guy that she needs to "move on"?! If I knew why (even if I didn't want to know why or like the reason or believe it) at least i could understand it.

 

Understanding is really important for me. Especially right now. Help me understand why I spend 19 years with her. Begged to hold her hand - to no avail. Longed to take her for a weekend to a B&B alone just to sit by the fire and read with her - never.

 

Why does she blame me?! Is it easier to blame me than for her to deal with her own unhappiness?

Link to comment
Hope - to the point. I like that. Hurts. But I like it.

 

WHY?!!?! Why is she done with this marriage? What have I done to be such a lousy guy that she needs to "move on"?! If I knew why (even if I didn't want to know why or like the reason or believe it) at least i could understand it.

 

Understanding is really important for me. Especially right now. Help me understand why I spend 19 years with her. Begged to hold her hand - to no avail. Longed to take her for a weekend to a B&B alone just to sit by the fire and read with her - never.

 

Why does she blame me?! Is it easier to blame me than for her to deal with her own unhappiness?

 

I know you were asking Hope and I know she'll give a good answer but I had to say...

 

DUDE!!! You KNOW all the answers to these questions. Say them....say it!

Link to comment

LOL Awdreee!! I'm not your husband.

 

And thanks for the "dude". It made me laugh and I haven't done a lot of that lately.

 

I know. I know. My kids will be gone soon. I just don't want to lose them sooner than I'd have to. I love coming home to them. Helping them do homework. Eating dinner next to them. ALL of that changes with divorce. I like loading us all into the family truckster and going for pizza. The simple things that get destroyed by divorce - I know, my dad left. I was much older (college) so his leaving wasn't a horrible big deal and my mom ended up with a very decent guy and together they are doing well.

 

Sigh.

 

I know that when they are gone, without change my wife and I will be lost together. There are times when it's so good to just sit with her...but those times are fading. I used to enjoy when she'd put her feet in my lap and I'd rub them. Now she won't let me. Or I'd rub her back in bed... haven't been allowed to do that for many months.

 

Strange - both you and Hope are both saying what the therapist said "don't see much hope". Sorry for the pun, Hope.

 

I guess part of me feels that there's more I could do. I've made mistakes. Nothing huge. No girlfriends, no money matters.

 

The guilt will eat me alive if I felt there was more that I could/should have done to be a better husband.

 

This is going to really suck, isn't it...

Link to comment

Awdree... I'm not sure I know. You say I do... DO I?

 

I don't think I've done anything lousy. I've done some stupid stuff here and there - a heck of a lot less than other husband.

 

She's just not happy. Period. And she hates that I am a happy guy. She hates that I'm successful. Hates that I can be level headed and at ease with the knuckleheads in customer service.

 

She's just a sad person. Her mom is too. And there's nothing that I can do to change that.

 

Why she wants to leave? I don't really know. Maybe she's tired of me trying to make her happy. Tired of me trying to help her see the right (my?!) way. Tired of me not getting all worked up over the things she get all worked up over. She wants me to get p/o at the customer service people. I don't. I won't. I get my way a different way.

 

I stayed for 19 years because I love her. But she doesn't love me at least not in a normal way.

 

And now I'm crying like a stupid baby...

Link to comment

Soon - I hate to be a giver-upper......I hate to say all is lost.......

 

Well...let's do this...

 

You've obviously approached her about the counseling thing.

 

You've obviously asked her what she thinks is left, yeh?

You've asked her to tell you what she thinks YOU can do to turn this around, right?

You've obviously told her about what you want and how you feel????

 

AND??

 

Is she dismissive?? Or does it make her stop and think....even if only momentarily?

Link to comment

When you said "She just has NO clue of what the real world is - cause she doesn't live in the real world" i find that really disrespectful of you.. It sounds as though even though you say what a fabulous home maker she is, you don't really respect the role at all..."She just has NO clue of what the real world is - cause she doesn't live in the real world... " Well it's her world and you need understand that many people live as home makers. It's a legitimate life whether you think so or not.. and much harder that you will ever know or choose to know! You say how lovely you are and what great money you make! Woo Hoo! Big Deal! You're obviously not good at keeping your woman happy!! Why would she get soooo frustrated as to throw things at you??!! Is she just crazy like you are implying or perhaps YOU, yes YOU may have something to do with her feeling like she's dying inside?...Money doesn;t fix everyghing. look in the mirror! Ask her some questions.. Put her FIRST..and not with the hope of romance as the reward. Build a friendship with your wife. Hang out. cause it's clear that it's all going to crumble very soon..

I hope this doesn't sound too harsh but i want you to really try getting to know your wife again as a woman. She sounds as tho she's taken on the wife and mother role to the point where she's lost herself.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...