Jump to content

I told my wife a secret and now we are in bad place


calus

Recommended Posts

My wife and I have been married for 10 years (both aged 28 now )and together for 14 years. We have 4 beautiful children together who are healthy and good kids.

when i met my wife i was immigrant and my parents were political asylum seekers . We connected because her mother and her had been stationed in my home country with the army and she spoke my language fluently having lived there for a few years .

 

I never told my wife that my grandfather who had a large stake in a oil company left me large sums of money and a few properties because that was simply not something we spoke about in our family.

We all knew what we each inherited and we had left that part of the world behind but some years back the political situation had changed and the government allowed my family to return.

 

my wife found out and feels like i hid the fact that i come from a oil family.

 

She is giving me the silent treatment for 5 days now.

Link to comment
  • Replies 57
  • Created
  • Last Reply

How did your wife find this out? You need to suggest marriage therapy, if you want this to work. That's quite a lie and changes her thinking, that perhaps you wanted a sham marriage of convenience. What is your goal? Stay married? Stay where you are? Go back to your country. How will you collect this inheritance?

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...

My wife and I are not talking due a me not having told her that i come from a wealthy family. My family were political refugees and we did not tell anyone this part of our life. The political situation in my home country improved and she came to find out about money she feels i did not tell her about. .

She packed her stuff and has taken the children to her mothers.

 

There have been moment that we struggled financially and she feels that I made us suffer for nothing.

 

what can i do to get my family back

Link to comment
There have been moment that we struggled financially and she feels that I made us suffer for nothing.

This is hard to understand. You say you have so much wealth/money, so I am not sure why you didn't use this money to sort out whatever "financial struggle" was going on. Makes no sense to me. I can sort of see why she would be upset if this is the case - why you let the family suffer when you had all this wealth which could have sorted things out. Just seems very odd.

Link to comment
This is hard to understand. You say you have so much wealth/money, so I am not sure why you didn't use this money to sort out whatever "financial struggle" was going on. Makes no sense to me. I can sort of see why she would be upset if this is the case - why you let the family suffer when you had all this wealth which could have sorted things out. Just seems very odd.

 

government seized our wealth shares froze my father bank account, we had nothing we started from scratch. We have since received royal pardons and my wife walked in on that conversation being discussed.

Link to comment

"What can I do to get my family back"

 

(1) Acknowledge that you are a team, that you are united in life and in all that life entails.

(2) Acknowledge that, by keeping information from her, you deprived her of the opportunity to understand you. You pretended to share with her whatever anxieties may have arisen because of the hardship, while keeping from her information that might have given her hope.

(3) Acknowledge that hiding or keeping relevant information from her is detrimental to your relationship together, because it makes it more difficult for her to know you and therefore more difficult to love you. And, practically speaking, more difficult to make decisions as a team, given that only one of you is informed.

(4) Apologize for the barriers you created between you. Explain that you did not understand the impact of your choices, and having learned from this experience, you would make different choices. Explain what you would do differently -- that you would share the information, share the ideas that you struggle with, seek her counsel, and seek her understanding.

(5) Explain that due to the family circumstances, you had deeply seated fears about the family wealth. That it isn't yours, exactly. That you had wanted to be certain you could survive without it, especially since it was nearly lost.

(6) Explain that the financial hardship was painful for everyone, and yet it was a gift too. By pulling through it, together, you gained confidence in yourself, and perhaps the two of you gained confidence in each other. You see that you can face hardships together and succeed in the face of difficulty.

(7) Acknowledge that Yes, you could have used family money to relieve their pain. Acknowledge that it may have been better to do so -- except that then, you would have felt dependent upon it. Beholden to others, and unable to stand on your own two feet.

(8) Apologize, again, for the pain of the hardship.

(9) Thank her for having faith in you, for believing you two would pull out of it and find better times.

(10) Thank her for her strength.

(11) Thank her for appreciating you as the man you are, apologize for having to learn a lesson (that you can stand on your own two feet) at the cost of the family's comfort. Assure her that now that you have gained more wisdom, you would be able to accept inherited wealth and spend it if/when necessary. And include her in your financial planning decisions, going forward.

 

What is unclear from your post:

Is this family wealth yours to spend/invest/manage as you please?

Is this wealth something you intend to keep to yourself, or do you intend to open it up for family needs?

 

If it isn't yours alone, then it isn't yours. And certainly isn't hers.

If you intend or are required to control this wealth individually and/or for the benefit of your birth family/siblings/parents, then you need to be clear about your role, and the fact that the money isn't as available to you as it might seem.

 

If the money is available to you, and was when you needed it but you chose to hide the money instead, then you need to be clear about why you made that choice, take responsibility for letting the family struggle, and point out the benefits of that. You also need to be clear about how you will behave going forward. Take responsibility for damaging your relationship by hiding something from her, and assure her that now you want to make decisions as a team, even difficult decisions. Especially the difficult ones.

 

In return you will need her understanding. Earn that by offering her your own.

Link to comment

 

If it isn't yours alone, then it isn't yours. And certainly isn't hers.

If you intend or are required to control this wealth individually and/or for the benefit of your birth family/siblings/parents, then you need to be clear about your role, and the fact that the money isn't as available to you as it might seem.

 

If the money is available to you, and was when you needed it but you chose to hide the money instead, then you need to be clear about why you made that choice, take responsibility for letting the family struggle, and point out the benefits of that. You also need to be clear about how you will behave going forward. Take responsibility for damaging your relationship by hiding something from her, and assure her that now you want to make decisions as a team, even difficult decisions. Especially the difficult ones.

 

In return you will need her understanding. Earn that by offering her your own.

 

This money was not available to me until recently when my family received a royal pardon. in fact we were unable to visit my country as we would be thrown in prison for simply entering the country. My father has been trying for the better part of 11 years to make amends and it eventually worked out positively. I have never discussed that part of my life with my spouse as it never seemed to come to anything .

 

we struggling financially and i didn't want to make a bad situation worse by mentioning money i did not have access to . Just imagine welfare and talking to your wife and kids about money which might or might not come.

 

now however things have changed and everyone will get a payout from the government and compensation for the years we are unable to receive any money.

She feels like i have kept something from her and that i didn't trust her enough to let her know that my father was working with the embassy in trying to fix the situation.

 

I just didn't think it would ever work out it eventually took 11 years to fix

Link to comment
This money was not available to me until recently when my family received a royal pardon. in fact we were unable to visit my country as we would be thrown in prison for simply entering the country. My father has been trying for the better part of 11 years to make amends and it eventually worked out positively. I have never discussed that part of my life with my spouse as it never seemed to come to anything .

 

we struggling financially and i didn't want to make a bad situation worse by mentioning money i did not have access to . Just imagine welfare and talking to your wife and kids about money which might or might not come.

 

now however things have changed and everyone will get a payout from the government and compensation for the years we are unable to receive any money.

She feels like i have kept something from her and that i didn't trust her enough to let her know that my father was working with the embassy in trying to fix the situation.

 

I just didn't think it would ever work out it eventually took 11 years to fix

 

To recap:

 

You didn't have any money with which to fix everything.

What you kept to yourself was the potential to receive money.

 

Your wife knew of your refugee/ex-pat status and the family history of having left your homeland? She knew of your family, she knew your background?

 

Then still, go through the steps of acknowledging that you kept something from her, as discussed below.

Hiding something always prevents someone else from understanding you fully. Hence, your silence put you two at a distance from one another, and that was not your intention. Take responsibility for that.

 

Ask permission to share your experience and your desire to avoid disappointment. Share your emotional landscape. Your logic.

 

Tell her that you learned from this experience how important it is to let her know your thoughts.

 

-- Make sure she understands you could not have changed your financial position, previously.

 

Listen to her. Listen to her more than seems logical. Her trust is diminished, and it is unclear why: Perhaps, she needed some kind of hope, whereas you needed to assume you would never get anything to ensure you would find a way to live without it.

 

You are different people. She expected something from you that you didn't provide. That doesn't mean you don't love her. You do want to provide & protect your family to your greatest ability. And that is what you did, by using whatever resources you had, and protecting them from expecting resources you didn't have and had no expectation of receiving. You were trying to protect the people you love as best you know how.

Link to comment

It's rather odd that you'd keep your family history and a matter of such importance from your wife and the reasons you give don't seem to explain it. I get why she feels somewhat betrayed but the 5 day silent treatment is childish and nonproductive.

 

Tell her to grow up and wait for the money to start rolling in and leave it at that.

Link to comment

I just can't tell how much was hidden, if it was just the money, or if was the whole family history.

 

If it was just the money, in my judgment, her reaction is unfounded. BUT I AM NOT HER. If you love her, take her as she is and give her the assurances she requires. Judging her is divisive. Her emotional reaction and her decision to pack up the kids and leave demonstrates that she is overwhelmed.

 

-- When you get to the point of having a conversation, suggest you both invest in some skill building. Whether through reading, classes, or therapy, you both have skills to learn about intimacy and conflict resolution. Kids need stability. So do adults.

 

She can take her grievances up with you in private. Moving out is divisive and undermines the relationship.

 

The biggest indicator of long term marriages is the couples' ability to resolve conflict. If you intend to stay together, you both will need better skills.

Link to comment

(and sorry to add this but, one must consider the fact that perhaps, this marriage is not well made. If you are open to that idea, then be careful how you receive and spend the money that comes in, as it may become family property and you would lose it if you split up.)

 

Mostly, though, I think the two of you need to trust intentions for each other, and accept each other as flawed. Because we are human, we will make mistakes and we will make decisions with which the other disagrees, and we will hurt one another entirely without intention or awareness. It is what we do. She will need to learn to be responsible for her decision to stay with you, and find the skills and strength to weather the stormy times. Trusting you with her hurt and her fears is an intimate act and she needs to learn that. Trusting her with your hopes and dreams is an intimate act, and you need to learn to do that. Tell her to remember it is a wish/dream/hope, and therefore, is only an idea. That you will need to trust her not to be unhappy if it never happens.

 

It is all a give and take.

Link to comment

So...what does this inheritence mean?

 

I mean, if i had a rich relative leave me money, i would not believe my good fortune and tell my guy of the windfall.

It would change our lives.

She could fear you will just return to that country and leave her behind

She could fear you will require that she move.

Is this something you are going to not share with her and your children?

are the children unsafe from the people that expelled your parents?

Has it come to light that your parents did things that were unsavory to your wife and her family?

Link to comment

As most of you have guessed i have never discussed the family history with her because it was a sore spot for us all. Kept it light my dad is an engineer and my mom is a homemaker type thing. She knew we left because my dad made some inflammatory statements about the royal family but we never really discussed what my family did .

 

I see now that i should have been clearer about my family history and that it was unwise to sort of gloss over that and leave most parts unsaid.

I have no intention of leaving im fine with my monthly share being deposited in a bank located in another country i am fine with that.

 

I never discussed it all simply because it hurt and i didn't want to open up an old wound. We had meet up with family in foreign countries for the past 11 years it was just horrible . Today ill go down and have a talk with her and with the kids about what happened and what the situation is now and that our lives will remain unchanged for the most part.

apologize and ask them to come back

Link to comment
My wife and I are not talking due a me not having told her that i come from a wealthy family. My family were political refugees and we did not tell anyone this part of our life. The political situation in my home country improved and she came to find out about money she feels i did not tell her about. .

She packed her stuff and has taken the children to her mothers.

 

There have been moment that we struggled financially and she feels that I made us suffer for nothing.

 

what can i do to get my family back

 

 

I'm sorry, "My husband has more money than I thought" now I pout? I'm so confused. I would be playing "celebrate good times come on!"

Link to comment

Is she upset about money or that you were living a lie for so long and your entire history, family history, reason for emigrating, etc was all a lie and your marriage was a sham all along because supposedly "it hurt too much to tell your wife", which in itself is a lie.

Link to comment

Let's start NOW with being more careful with your word choice. It seems you have a habit of obfuscation.

 

You did not tell your wife a secret. She walked in on a conversation.

 

Would you have told her? I don't think so. Given how much you left out, how would this news make any sense now? And, what good is this money if you can't get to it?

 

Your family history shaped who you are. Why didn't you share your history? She thinks she is that person to whom you can say anything. Or, she THOUGHT that. Now, it seems you keep anything important to yourself, and to her, you present a sanitized version of who you are.

 

She may logically wonder Who are you? What else is unknown?

Link to comment
The danger aspect , to her, the family, by your political situation. Was there any and is there any now?

 

There was non to her or the children and there is certainly non now.

 

We have decided to take a break from each other reevaluate the relationship. She is coming home today and i am leaving the house so she can decide what is best for her and the children without her mother looking over her shoulder.

 

She wants to go to marriage counseling when she feels ready until then i am going to rent a room a mile or a so from where I currently live.

Link to comment

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...