Parents with Mental Illness : The Scope of the Issue, Part 2

by SAMHSA

(Page 3 of 20)

Public Sector Data

Available data from public sector management information systems sources, such as state mental health agency case management records, indicate a significant percent of adult clients receiving public sector mental health services are parents. Data from the New York State Office of Mental Health indicated that 45% of women under the age of 35 receiving intensive case management services have children, and of these, 20% are identified as the custodial parent (Blanch, Nicholson & Purcell, 1994). Analyses of Massachusetts Department of Mental Health (MA/DMH) case management rosters in the early 1990's indicated that approximately 9% of the total MA/DMH client population of adult women with serious and persistent mental illness were identified as having dependent children (White et al., 1995).

The knowledge gained from existing sources like these is routinely compromised by "sampling error," and deficits in the questions asked. For example, prevalence estimates culled from public sector mental health systems sources represent the sub-sample of adults diagnosed with mental illness who are in greatest need, who meet eligibility criteria regarding severity and duration of illness and functional impairment and, oftentimes, additional criteria such as multiple hospitalizations or homelessness. It is difficult to generalize from these data to the general population of individuals with mental illness that includes those receiving services in the private sector, or those not receiving services at all.

Often the right set of questions is not asked. For example, in completing the MA/DMH client tracking forms from the early 1990's, which have since been revised, the case manager checked a box if a client was known to "have a dependent child." This category was defined as "client is the primary caretaker for a minor child." First, a check in this box was based on the case manager's knowledge of the client's parenting status and history. Second, a check reflected knowledge only of those with children under the age of 18, with whom the adult was actively involved. Therefore, information was not recorded about children ever born who might be adults themselves, or those who might be living independently or in alternative family situations with relatives, foster parents or adoptive parents. In addition, information was not routinely obtained about pregnancy status or whether adults were considering becoming pregnant.

It is important to note that Massachusetts was not alone, by any means, in overlooking this information. In our original survey of SMHAs, conducted in 1990 and 1991, only 16 SMHAs routinely asked whether clients were parents (Nicholson et al., 1993). This state-level oversight is repeated at the clinical level in inpatient and outpatient psychiatric settings, where records do not contain this information (DeChillo, Koren & Schultze, 1994; Rudolph, Larson, Sweeny, Hough & Arorian, 1990). Information is not routinely obtained about whether adults with mental illness have even given birth to or fathered a child, the ages of these children, where they are living, or who is caring for them. And yet the likelihood that parents comprise a significant percent of inpatient or outpatient populations is high.

In Massachusetts, clinicians completed surveys at three sites-a Massachusetts Department of Mental Health case management site, the outpatient department of a community mental health center site, and a site providing both case management and outpatient treatment services (Nicholson, unpublished raw data). The percent of female outpatient clients who are mothers ranged from 33% to 50%. Twenty-one percent of male clients are known by clinicians to be fathers (Nicholson, Nason, Calabresi & Yando, 1999). The average number of children born to each parent is a little over two, suggesting these families are similar to the national average. Again, these prevalence figures must be considered underestimates as they are data obtained from clinicians, not the clients themselves, and these sites serve the small slice of the population diagnosed with severe and lengthy illnesses.

While individual states and agencies have modified forms and procedures to begin to collect this information, our recent survey of state mental health agencies, conducted in 1999, indicates that an even lower number of SMHAs (12) than the number in 1990 (16) are collecting this information on a routine basis. While SMHAs may justify this lack of data collection by pointing to the privatization of the case management function, or as the responsibility of managed care organizations and providers, this abdication of responsibility robs the SMHAs of opportunities to promote quality care through the development of relevant policies, regulations, procedures, and services. Adequate policy development, program planning or clinical care, to address the issues and meet the needs of adults with mental illness and their children, cannot occur without accurate prevalence data, and more detailed information about the circumstances, goals and needs of these families.

SUMMARY: There are no national data on the prevalence of adults with mental illness becoming parents and raising children, nor do data exist describing their children. Efforts to extrapolate these figures from existing data sets or community clinic sites are limited by the types of questions asked and populations served. Parents with mental illness are not routinely asked comprehensive questions about their family or household circumstances. Therefore policies and programs have not necessarily been developed with adequate information to meet the needs or goals of adults with mental illness as parents or the needs of their children. We know nothing about the prevalence of parents with mental illness in the private sector, nor about parents who are undiagnosed or not receiving treatment. Likewise, we know nothing about their children's circumstances or needs.

RECOMMENDATIONS: Adults with mental illness must be asked the "right" set of questions regarding their status as parents and their family circumstances. For example, women and men must be asked whether they have ever given birth to or fathered a child; the dates of birth and genders of their children; where their children are living; and who is caring for them. Adults with mental illness may be caring for adopted children, stepchildren or the children of others in informal arrangements as well. The issue of who has custody of children is a distinct question from the question of where children are living, who is caring for them, or the extent or nature of contact or involvement their parent with mental illness has with them. Policy makers and service providers must also ask about adults' wishes or goals for parenting, as they may differ from their current family situations. Adults' goals should be respected in service planning, as they affect adults' compliance with treatment recommendations, and outcomes for both parents and children. Children's circumstances and needs must be explored and documented.

About the Author

www.samhsa.gov
SAMHSA works to improve the quality and availability of substance abuse prevention, alcohol and drug addiction treatment, and mental health services. Includes links to support groups, information resources, events and articles.